​What Can I Do if an Insurance Company Denies My Car Accident Claim?

Written by Christopher D. Alas, Esq. · Reviewed by Christopher D. Alas, Esq.Founding & Managing Attorney✓ Fact Checked Legally reviewed by Christopher D. Alas, Esq.Founding …
​What Can I Do if an Insurance Company Denies My Car Accident Claim
Christopher D. Alas, Esq.
Founding & Managing Attorney
✓ Fact Checked
Christopher D. Alas, Esq.
Legally reviewed by Christopher D. Alas, Esq.
Founding & Managing Attorney
✓ Fact Checked

If you suffer injuries in a car accident, you might already know that you have a right to seek compensation for medical expenses and lost wages due to your injuries. However, filing an insurance claim can be a demanding and challenging process. One of the most frustrating situations injury claimants face is when an insurance company denies their valid claim.

If this has happened to you, you might feel overwhelmed with questions and concerns. How will you be able to afford your medical bills? What if you fall behind on living expenses because you miss time at work? Why did the insurer deny your claim in the first place?

A denial does not always end the matter. What you can do next depends mostly on which claim was denied: a personal injury protection (PIP) claim with your own insurer, a liability claim against the at-fault driver’s insurer, or an uninsured motorist (UM) claim under your own policy. Florida law gives you different tools for each, and the sections below walk through them in that order.

How Do Car Accident Claims Work in Florida?

Florida is a no-fault car accident state. However, this phrase does not mean that no one is ever to blame for an accident. Instead, Florida’s no-fault laws mean that a motorist will seek compensation first from their own insurance via personal injury protection (PIP), regardless of who is at fault.

Under Florida law, all drivers must have a minimum of $10,000 in PIP coverage.

When a driver gets into an accident, their insurance policy will cover:

For a PIP claim, you must receive initial treatment within 14 days of the accident. Under section 627.736(4)(b), PIP benefits become overdue if they are not paid within 30 days after the insurer receives written notice of the covered loss and its amount.

If the insurer pays only part of a PIP bill or rejects it, the statute requires it to provide an itemized specification of each item it declined to pay and the reason. Keep that explanation, because it frames everything that follows.

Start Here: Which Claim Was Denied?

The table below summarizes the main options for each type of claim. A lawyer can confirm which applies to your situation, because a single crash can involve all three.

Denied claimWho you are dealing withFlorida tools that may apply
PIP benefitsYour own insurerItemized written explanation, revised claim, pre-suit demand letter under section 627.736(10), then a lawsuit for overdue benefits
Bodily injury liabilityThe at-fault driver’s insurerMore evidence and negotiation, mediation for smaller claims, and a lawsuit against the at-fault driver (not the insurer)
Uninsured motoristYour own insurerPolicy dispute procedures, a lawsuit under the policy, and a civil remedy notice if the insurer may be acting in bad faith

What if My PIP Policy Does Not Cover My Losses?

If your medical expenses or lost wages exceed $10,000 and your injuries meet the state’s severity threshold, you can seek compensation via the at-fault driver’s bodily injury (BI) liability insurance policy, if they have one.

If not, you can apply to your own uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM) policy, if you have one. These policies may allow you to seek compensation for a greater amount of money and for a wider variety of losses than a PIP claim allows. You could also have the option of filing a lawsuit against the at-fault driver.

Why Did the Insurer Deny My Claim?

Claims can be denied for reasons that are legitimate, reasons that rest on missing information, and reasons you may be able to dispute. Even your own insurer evaluates a claim against the policy language and the evidence it has.

Here are some of the most common reasons adjusters give for denying or reducing a car accident claim.

Your Medical Treatment Was Unnecessary

PIP pays for reasonable, medically necessary care. If the insurer decides a treatment was not necessary or that a charge was unreasonable, it may reduce or deny that item. Treatment notes, diagnostic results, and a clear explanation from your provider of why each service was needed can help you respond.

Your Treatment Did Not Receive the Correct Medical Approval

PIP pays for initial services and care only from the provider types listed in section 627.736(1)(a), such as a licensed physician, osteopathic physician, chiropractic physician, dentist, or certain hospital and emergency providers. Follow-up care from some providers, such as physical therapists, generally requires a referral. The full $10,000 medical benefit also requires a qualifying provider to determine that you had an emergency medical condition; otherwise medical benefits are limited to $2,500.

You Waited Too Long to Seek Medical Treatment

PIP requires initial treatment within 14 days of the accident. Liability and UM insurers do not apply that specific rule, but they may argue that a long gap between the crash and treatment suggests the injury came from something else.

Many people do not realize they have suffered an injury until several days or even weeks after a traffic collision, as certain symptoms can remain hidden for a long time. This delayed onset is one reason you should consult with a medical professional immediately after being in an accident. A physician’s examination may discover injuries you did not realize you had.

You Missed the Deadline to Make a Claim

Beyond the 14-day treatment rule, your policy likely requires prompt notice of the accident and cooperation with the investigation. Under section 627.736(6)(g) and (7), a PIP insurer can require an examination under oath and a medical examination, and failing to attend can cut off benefits. Read your policy carefully, and consult with an experienced Florida car accident attorney if any requirement is unclear.

Your Injuries Were Due to a Pre-Existing Condition

​What Can I Do if an Insurance Company Denies My Car Accident Claim

A pre-existing condition is an injury or medical condition you had before the accident. For example, if you suffered a herniated disc five years before the crash, your insurer might deny your claim because the injury pre-dated and was therefore unrelated to the collision.

However, you might still qualify for compensation if the accident exacerbated a pre-existing injury. Seeking medical treatment immediately after the collision can help your doctor determine whether your injuries have worsened. Speaking with a qualified attorney can help you understand whether you still have a valid claim.

Your Injuries Are Unrelated to the Car Accident

Many people receive denials for their claims because their insurer decides that their injuries did not occur due to the traffic collision. In many cases, this outcome is the result of a delay between the car accident and when the claimant sought medical treatment. The more time passes between the two events, the more justification an insurance adjuster has for declaring a lack of causality.

If you did not seek early treatment after an accident, you can strengthen your case by gathering as much evidence as possible to demonstrate the link between the crash and your injuries.

You Were Driving Another Person’s Car Without Their Permission

If you suffered injuries in an accident while driving another person’s car, an insurer might not cover your accident-related losses by claiming the owner did not permit you to operate their vehicle. A lawyer can help you prove that you had either implied or explicit consent to do so.

Your Insurance Policy Has Lapsed

Your claim will not be valid if you file it after your policy has lapsed. Always keep your insurance current so you can comply with state law and protect your right to compensation.

Your Policy Does Not Cover the Losses You Claim

Insurance policies cover a specific set of losses, and requesting compensation for anything else will result in a denied claim.

For example, PIP does not cover:

Recovering these losses may require you to file a claim against another type of insurance policy if applicable. If not, you can try to recover these damages in a personal injury lawsuit.

What Happens if an Insurer Denies My Claim for No Reason?

When an insurer denies a claim, it should explain why. If the explanation does not match the facts or the policy, ask for it in writing and ask which policy provision the insurer is relying on. Most denials turn out to be disputes over evidence, coverage, or valuation rather than misconduct.

If an insurer may not have attempted in good faith to settle a claim when it could and should have, Florida’s section 624.155 allows a civil action. Before filing, the claimant must give the Department of Financial Services and the insurer 60 days’ written notice through a civil remedy notice, and no action lies if the insurer pays the damages or corrects the violation within those 60 days. Recent amendments also give liability insurers a safe harbor in some cases if they tender the lesser of the policy limits or the amount demanded within 90 days, and they place a duty of good faith on claimants as well. These claims are technical, so talk with a Florida auto accident attorney before sending a notice.

How Do I Appeal a Decision?

Auto insurers do not usually have a formal “appeal” like a health plan, but you can ask the adjuster to reconsider. That typically means sending a written response with the missing records, a provider’s explanation, photos, or witness statements that address the stated reason for denial. For a PIP claim, the statute also gives you a short window to submit a revised claim when a bill was denied because of a coding or billing error.

Mediation and Complaints to the State

Under section 627.745, either party may demand mediation before a lawsuit is filed for a motor vehicle personal injury claim of $10,000 or less, or for a property damage claim in any amount, and the insurer generally bears the cost of the mediation conference. You can also file a consumer complaint with the Florida Department of Financial Services, which can ask the insurer to respond, although the department does not decide the value of your claim.

The PIP Demand Letter

Before suing your insurer for overdue PIP benefits, section 627.736(10) requires written notice of your intent to file suit. If the insurer pays the overdue amount within 30 days after receiving the notice, plus interest and a penalty of 10 percent capped at $250, the suit cannot proceed. The demand letter must contain specific information, so it is worth having a lawyer prepare it.

A car accident lawyer can review your policy and determine how to strengthen your claim. They can also negotiate with the insurance company on your behalf. Furthermore, your lawyer can also conduct independent investigations into the accident, potentially uncovering information that can help refute the insurer’s grounds for denying your application.

When Should I File a Lawsuit?

Although Florida is a no-fault car accident state, you still have the right to file a lawsuit under certain circumstances.

When an Insurer Denies Your Valid Claim

If your own insurer denies a valid PIP or UM claim and reconsideration does not resolve it, you may be able to sue the insurer under the policy after meeting the pre-suit requirements above. A third-party liability claim works differently. Under section 627.4136, you generally cannot sue the at-fault driver’s insurer directly until you first obtain a settlement or verdict against its insured, so the lawsuit is filed against the driver, and the insurer usually provides the defense. Our article on how often car accident claims go to court explains what that process looks like.

When You Have Suffered a Significant or Permanent Injury

Florida’s no-fault system limits lawsuits against at-fault drivers for pain and suffering. Under section 627.737, you may sue for those damages only if your injury meets the statutory threshold, which is often called the significant or permanent injury requirement.

The statute lists these categories:

An attorney can review your medical records, determine whether your injuries meet the threshold, and if they do, pursue the at-fault driver for the losses PIP does not cover.

Some drivers opt to carry bodily injury (BI) liability insurance to protect themselves when they are at fault for a car accident that causes a significant or permanent injury. If the driver has this coverage, your attorney can negotiate a settlement with their provider to resolve your claim against them.

However, if the at-fault driver only meets the state’s legal minimum insurance requirements, their policies may not cover the losses you suffer as a result of their negligence. If your expenses go beyond the limits of your PIP insurance, you may have the right to file a lawsuit against them.

Lawsuits under these circumstances can be complicated, particularly when the at-fault driver carries little or no bodily injury coverage. In that case, your own UM coverage may be the most practical source of payment, which our guide to accidents with an underinsured driver explains in detail.

A car accident lawyer can also check whether anyone else shares responsibility, such as an employer or the owner of the vehicle, and whether the at-fault driver has non-exempt assets that could satisfy a judgment.

What Compensation Can I Get in a Florida Car Accident Lawsuit?

While your PIP insurance may limit your compensation to certain medical expenses and a portion of your lost wages, you could recover a great deal more through a lawsuit.

Depending on your circumstances, the court may grant you compensation for:

The value of some of these losses can be difficult to calculate. A lawyer can help you estimate the range of compensation that may be available and explain how fault, coverage limits, and medical evidence may affect it.

What Should I Do Next?

Christopher D. Alas, Car Motorycle Accident Lawyer

If an insurance company denies your car accident claim, the next step depends on which claim was denied and why. The Miami car accident lawyers at Redemption Law can review the denial letter, your policy, and your medical records, explain the options Florida law gives you, and talk with you about next steps during a free consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions About Denied Car Accident Claims

How long does a Florida insurer have to pay a PIP claim?

Under section 627.736(4)(b), PIP benefits are overdue if they are not paid within 30 days after the insurer receives written notice of the covered loss and its amount. If the insurer pays only part of a bill or rejects it, it must provide an itemized explanation of what it declined and why.

Can I sue the other driver’s insurance company for denying my claim?

Usually not right away. Florida’s nonjoinder statute, section 627.4136, generally requires you to obtain a settlement or verdict against the insured driver before you can bring an action against the liability insurer. In most cases, the lawsuit is filed against the at-fault driver.

What is a civil remedy notice in Florida?

A civil remedy notice is the written notice required by section 624.155 before a bad faith action against an insurer. It is filed with the Department of Financial Services and sent to the insurer, which then has 60 days to pay the damages or correct the problem before a lawsuit can proceed.

Do I need a demand letter before suing for PIP benefits?

Yes. Section 627.736(10) requires written notice of your intent to file suit before an action for overdue PIP benefits. If the insurer pays the overdue amount with interest and a capped penalty within 30 days of receiving the letter, no lawsuit may be brought for those benefits.

Can mediation help with a denied car accident claim?

It can for some claims. Section 627.745 lets either party demand mediation before a lawsuit for a motor vehicle personal injury claim of $10,000 or less, or a property damage claim in any amount. The insurer generally pays for the mediation conference, and only one mediation is usually allowed per claim.

Christopher D. Alas, Esq.
Legally reviewed by
Founding & Managing Attorney, Redemption Law, PLLC

Christopher D. Alas is the founder and managing attorney of Redemption Law, a personal injury firm licensed in Texas and Florida. He oversees the firm’s litigation strategy and draws on a background in tax law to help clients understand the financial and legal implications of their injury claims. Read full bio

Christopher D. Alas, Esq.
Legally reviewed by
Founding & Managing Attorney, Redemption Law, PLLC

Christopher D. Alas is the founder and managing attorney of Redemption Law, a personal injury firm licensed in Texas and Florida. He oversees the firm’s litigation strategy and draws on a background in tax law to help clients understand the financial and legal implications of their injury claims. Read full bio